My House, My Rules? Not So Fast.

By: J. David Chapman, PhD, / December 11, 2026

Who gets to decide what you do with your property? You, your neighbors, or the Oklahoma Supreme Court? That question became more complicated this month when the Oklahoma Supreme Court ruled 5–4 in favor of a homeowner’s association in Edmond's Silverhawk neighborhood, effectively prohibiting a homeowner from operating a short-term rental.

The homeowner had been renting his house through Airbnb and Vrbo. The neighborhood's restrictive covenants required residential use and prohibited business operations. The association argued that short-term rentals constituted a business. The homeowner argued that people sleeping, eating, and living in a house were using it for residential purposes, regardless of how long they stayed.

Five justices agreed with the association. Four disagreed. And therein lies a fascinating debate about property rights. As a real estate investor, I believe strongly in property rights. After all, ownership should mean something. If I purchase a house, maintain it, and pay the taxes, shouldn't I have considerable freedom to decide how it is used?

But what about my neighbor? Suppose my neighbor purchased a home specifically because its restrictive covenants promised a certain residential environment. Doesn't that neighbor also have property rights, including the right to expect those restrictions to be enforced?

This is where individual property rights collide with collective property rights. The court's majority concluded that the short-term rental resembled a hotel or motel business. The property was advertised to transient guests, rented nightly, and operated with check-in and check-out times. The court determined these activities violated the neighborhood's prohibition against business use.

The dissenting justices disagreed, questioning whether the covenants clearly prohibited short-term rentals and arguing that restrictions on ownership should not extend beyond their language.

Here's where I struggle. If I rent my house to someone for a year, we call that residential use. If I rent it for a month, is it still residential? What about a week? A weekend?

At what point does residential use become commercial use? Certainly, the owner is conducting a business by collecting rent. But isn't a landlord collecting monthly rent also conducting a business? Does the length of the lease determine what happens inside the property?

There are legitimate concerns about short-term rentals. Increased traffic, unfamiliar visitors, parking problems, noise, and disruptive parties can change a neighborhood's character. But those problems can also occur with long-term tenants or owner-occupants.

Bad behavior is bad behavior, regardless of who holds the keys. The Silverhawk decision does not give every Oklahoma HOA unlimited authority to prohibit short-term rentals. The outcome depended on the neighborhood's covenants and the facts of the case. Interestingly, the restrictions did not specifically mention Airbnb or short-term rentals. The majority concluded that the existing business prohibition was sufficient.

That distinction matters. Perhaps the larger lesson is that restrictive covenants deserve more attention than most buyers give them. Those documents can protect property values and neighborhood expectations, but they can also limit how an owner uses an otherwise perfectly good investment.

I believe property rights are fundamental to real estate ownership. But those rights also include the ability of owners to agree to restrictions protecting their collective interests.

The challenge is deciding where one right ends and another begins. Five Oklahoma Supreme Court justices drew that line in one place. Four drew it somewhere else. Where would you draw it?

Dr. J. David Chapman is Chair of Finance & Professor of Real Estate at the University of Central Oklahoma (jchapman7@uco.edu).

Next
Next

The Things That Matter Most